Jeanine Wellinghoff
Kristen Grace
NNI vs Nanodocs
1. Purpose of Source
- NNI: There is a straight forward statement of intended purpose on the front page which covers all aspects of the page’s purpose. Basically a mission statement for the site. Also a very clear set of goals listed under the about page.
- Nanodocs: The intended purpose, while present, was difficult to find and much less clear. Mostly located on the about page, but predominately about the hospital, not nanotechology.
2. Coverage of a source
- NNI: Links to other resources available, a basic facts page is provided for the less knowledgeable about the topic. Lists not just information but also opportunities and uses.
- Nanodocs More specific audience, for a specific hospital, not written for the average person to understand. There are links other sites, not necessarily information resources.
3. Authority and Reputation
- NNI: Offshoot of the government. .gov page Federal site.
- Nanodocs: Created by a hospital so it’s most likely legit.
4. Accuracy
- NNI: Based on research done by the organizaton (federal research), most likely unbias and done through a government agency. Factual based on actual research.
- Nanodocs: Information and data researched by a data lab as part of teaching hospital. Factual based on actual research.
5. Currency
- NNI: Established in 2001, Updates present from 2008, well maintained, no broken links
- Nanodocs: Copyrighted 2001, broken links, updated to current events
6. Presentation
- NNI: Bare minimum layout, present site map, well written, easy to navigate and read, few images. Consistent layout.
- Nanodocs: very well created, futuristic, intractable, visually well created and appealing. Easy to navigate, clear links. Lots and lots of images. Consistant layout.
7. Other sites.
Delicious URL search
NNI: People have saved this 149 times, and 27 wrote notes – Much more well used.
Nanodocs: People have saved this 15 times, and 7 wrote notes – Rarely used.
We would definitely use the government site (NNI) for information. It is easier to use and provides easier to find and understand information, despite having a less visually appealing layout. Delicious confirmed our decision because obviously many people agreed with us.